|
Friday, June 6, 2003
Previous topic
|
Next topic
|
|
 Friday, June 6, 2003
started 6/6/2003; 12:12:24 AM - last post 6/6/2003; 10:46:22 PM
|
|
Doc Searls - Friday, June 6, 2003 
6/6/2003; 4:12:24 AM (reads: 7703, responses: 6)
|
|
A spectrum of questions 
| | Will this simply transfer spectrum from government agencies and the military to private licensees, or will the administration consider the more revolutionary change of opening up some of that spectrum on an unlicensed basis? |
| | If the democrats are the party of weath redistribution, and the republicans the party of wealth creation (an old and generally sensible republican claim), another question then becomes, Will the republican-led congress vote with The People for more open and free common spectrum to support more invention and entrepreneurship, as we're seeing with wi-fi today, or will it vote with the big boys and auction the spectrum off to the highest big boy bidders? |
| | We must unlock the economic value and entrepreneurial potential of U.S. spectrum assets while ensuring that sufficient spectrum is available to support critical government functions, |
| | "Economic value" translates to "auctions." "Entrepreneurial potential" translates to "open spectrum." |
| | Now the question isn't how to bet on the outcome. It's how to influence the outcome. |
Digging Dean
| | What makes a good poliblog? Human beings speaking in human voices (like Matthew Gross, who signed the latest several posts). Making the ends the means. Links galore. Cross-crediting where due. Permalinks. RSS. Involvement. All that stuff is good to see, regardless of the policies involved. |
| | Are any other candidates even close? |
| | While we're talking politics, there's this from another Dean. John. Counsel to Nixon. Yes, that Dean. |
| | To put it bluntly, if Bush has taken Congress and the nation into war based on bogus information, he is cooked. |
| | Thanks to Sean-Paul at The Agonist for the pointage. |
Q.O.D.
| | RSS newsreaders are TiVo for bloggers. |
| | Normally I'd append a pointer to the end of the post that occasioned it, but I thought this was too good not to give a post of its own. |
| | I responded to Phil's post here. |
The biggest Digital ID problem
| | The challenge is to reconcile two complementary yet superficially opposed points of view. |
| | On the other head, there are the natual creeps people get around the idea of new they-identify-us systems of any kind, even though our wallets are full of them. For that we have Stand, an organization in the U.K. that has successfully opposed government-enabled snoopage, among other things. Their site is titled A Cynic's Guideto Entitlement (*cough* ID *cough) Cards. |
| | My own libertarian take on the matter is to start by keeping the government out of it. |
More blog bashing
| | For examples he points to a bunch of sites I don't frequent, plus TiVo, which I don't use (but would if the company worked something out with DishTV, which instead prefers to sell captive customers its own DVR). Still, some of what he says rings true, some false. |
| | Sorry. I thought I saw something, but I can't find it now. |
| | But I¹d argue that certain information-delivering technologies — like TiVo and blogs — up the ante so dramatically, and so seamlessly, that they create an entirely different sort of interpassive lifestyle, one that¹s, well, hyperpassive. |
| | Wtf? Let's get this straight: A TiVo is a machine. A blog is a journal. Like comparing apples and noises. |
| | By the way, if I ever think what I'm doing here is "information delivery," or akin to television, I'll stop it in half a heartbeat. |
| | A home video library, or a physical collection of information of any sort, exists. The pleasure derives from the ownership of objects, but those objects—the piles of unread papers and magazines and books, the stacks of unwatched videotapes—also constantly taunt you, reminding you of their presence. |
| | Readers do that for me. One emailed me three times yesterday. Good stuff too. |
| | A machine removes that punishing presence. A blog, for instance, constantly pushes even slightly stale talking points to the margins (or the bottom of the homepage, or the archive). And while in hope-springs-eternal obliviousness you can always think, in the back of your mind, Oh, I¹ll go back and catch up on what I missed or I¹ll go back and read the article that was linked to, chances are it¹s not going to happen because there won¹t be any tangible evidence of your failure to do so. |
| | What¹s more, a machine erases not only physical boundaries (the information object vanishes) but psychological boundaries as well. The point where you begin and where the machine-generated awareness ends begins to blur. (I¹m starting to feel like I really have watched Tina and Clay.) |
| | The blog reader isn¹t thinking, Jim Romenesko is smart about media for me or Elizabeth Spiers is drolly engaged in Manhattanism for me. The reader is thinking, I¹m smart about media and I¹m drolly engaged in Manhattanism. |
| | And I really hate to do this, but I can¹t help but bring up that kid, Jayson what¹s-his-name, at the Times , who sat in his apartment with a laptop and a cell phone, collected all manner of information from disparate sources, and said to himself not only I am knowledgeable but I am a reporter. |
| | For him, firsthand experience was secondary: Life was blog, blog was life. |
| | The truth is, I¹m getting a little blurry myself on some of the boundaries (maybe this column is a cry for help), including the shape and scope of my own argument. If I¹m lucky, a clever blogger will summarize this column and crystallize its meaning not only for other readers but for me. (I can¹t tell you how many times Romenesko has blogged me and I¹ve thought, Oh, so that was my point.) |
| | Simon, you're conflating a whole buncha crap here and not making sense. I won't even bother quoting the earlier references to Lacan, Zizek and "interpassivity." You may be right about TiVo, but you're fulla gas on blogs. |
| | What's going on with blogs is the opposite of interpassivity. It's inteactivity. Literally. There is an immediate, first-hand, involved quality to writing here that doesn't happen elsewhere. I won't idealize it. It has shortcomings. But whatever it is, it's a breed apart from broadcasting and print journalism. Instead, it's a lot like what Benjamin Franklin was up to with Poor Richard's Almanac: personal, engaged, often quotable, sometimes enlightening, still experimental, and — what the hell: fun. |
| | By the way, while you were writing about getting nagged by unread papers and magazines, bloggers were nagging papers and magazines for washing their archives off the Web. And you know what? We got somewhere with it, too. At the New York Fucking Times, no less. Interactivity, dude. Involvement. Making stuff happen. Nothing passive about it. |
| | Meanwhile, I have to ask: Did you read this essay or did you read about it? |
| | A friend told me about it. Then I read it. Then I blogged about it. The beat goes on. |
discuss
|
|
Phil Wolff - RSS newsreaders are TiVo for blogs.
6/6/2003; 3:11:59 PM (reads: 5665, responses: 3)
|
|
|
The big fallacy is apples and oranges, movie cameras vs. movie theaters.
RSS newsreaders are TiVo for bloggers.
Newsreaders like NewzCrawler and Radio UserLand do TiVo things. Time shifting. Easier, more complete channel and program selection.Season pass for your favorite shows. Record in the background while playing in the foreground. Save a post to your blog instead of to your VCR.
TiVo needs blogspace community tools: add social filtering (recommendations), feedback, and threads of commentary.
discuss
|
|
Doc Searls - Re: RSS newsreaders are TiVo for blogs.
6/6/2003; 3:55:30 PM (reads: 2378, responses: 1)
|
|
|
Excellent. Just blogged it.
A thought:
While TiVo needs blogspace community tools, the chances it'll get them verge on zero, since TiVo is a commercial company that sells a largely closed and proprietary consumer electronics device to consumers, and a tightly licensed sofrware platform to OEMs. In other words, for all its hipness, it's still a consumer electronics company, living in the consumer electronics market habitat.
It's not about NEA.
In our habitat, the one that lives on the Net, we have NewsCrawler, Radio Userland, NetNewsWire Technorati, Blogdex, Daypop and all those other commercial conveniences (among the most inventive of which are commercial entities)l because they build on an underlying environment that nobody owns, everybody can use and anybody can improve. Hence all the invention and innovation.
The consumer electronics habitat, largely defined by cable, broadcasting and entertainment conglomerates and the regulatory agencies they essentially govern, broook no invention or innovation that doesn't come from inside their own labs, from their own engineers, for their own purposes as suppliers, distributors and facilitators of "content."
The fact that TiVo came out of Silicon Valley rather than Japan doesn't make it any less a creature of its category. Nor does the fact that it clearly threatens the business models (e.g. TV advertising) of many of its fellow market inhabitants.
My guess is that the dominant species in the consumer electronics habitat are cutting their teeth by crippling TiVo and others members of its species. They're getting practice for doing the same to Intel, IBM, Motorola and Apple (which is already making the changes necessary to live in the CE habitat).
Bonus reading: Which Side is TiVo on.
discuss
|
|
Renee Hopkins - Re: More blog bashing
6/6/2003; 7:11:07 PM (reads: 707, responses: 0)
|
|
|
After reading Dumenco's article (yes, Simon, many blog readers actually *do* follow source links!), I see how he's getting to this blogs-and-TiVo comparison -- both blogs and TiVo intimidate him because he can't keep up! So what does he do about *his* inability to find the time to watch the stuff he captures on TiVo....*his* inability to find the time to devote to careful blog-reading (following the links, commenting)... what does he do about this? Blame TiVo and blogging for the way he and the hip other "the pop-cultural literati" misuse them!!
Just look at the thesis of his argument: "But I¹d argue that certain information-delivering technologies — like TiVo and blogs — up the ante so dramatically, and so seamlessly, that they create an entirely different sort of interpassive lifestyle, one that¹s, well, hyperpassive."
Watch how this works: "They" -- TiVo and blogs -- create a lifestyle. Those people who are "TiVo'ing" reality shows they don't watch, and reading blog posts about articles they never follow the links to read themselves -- hey, it's not their responsibility to actually engage with life!
This is beyond clueless! This is like blaming the clock on the wall because *you're* late!
--Renee Hopkins (www.corante.com/ideaflow)
discuss
|
|
Michael Bernstein - Re: RSS newsreaders are TiVo for blogs.
6/6/2003; 8:50:10 PM (reads: 1220, responses: 0)
|
|
|
Before too long, TiVo (or anyone else playing in that space) will have to offer community tools because the Free-as-in-speech systems they're competing with will do so (though they haven't added anything like this yet). White box mom-and-pop shops will start getting into the game of bundling software like Freevo or MythTV with generic hardware and no service fees, and the CE giants simply won't be able to win at playing whack-a-mole with them (though I'm sure they'll cause some damage as they try).
discuss
|
|
lou josephs - blogs moved to a temp location
6/7/2003; 2:46:22 AM (reads: 742, responses: 0)
|
|
|
It's a dot net site. And it's fast too, templates need work though.
static.devfarm.com
discuss
|
|
Suman - Re: RSS newsreaders are TiVo for blogs.
12/26/2003; 10:32:16 PM (reads: 1190, responses: 0)
|
|
|
And now I want functions in RSS aggregators to record between dates. Record Jon's Radio from December 22nd till today and cache the referred pages so that I can take it on my laptop and read it offline. Or, I will leave my workstation running during holidays and please record all channels that mention the word "HyperChip".
Well, well, we are getting there. With blog recording, page caching and text filtering at our fingertips, the day is not far when we will finally be able to take long holidays and not worry about what we are missing.
discuss
|
|
|
Copyright 2009 The Doc Searls Weblog
|
