Home

Bio & Disclosures

Discussions


xFruits

2007 Events

Tuesday, February 5, 2002

Author:   Doc Searls  
Posted: 2/5/2002; 5:51:12 AM
Topic: Tuesday, February 5, 2002
Msg #: 1499 (top msg in thread)
Prev/Next: 1498/1500
Reads: 4716

But seriously, folks 
 One correspondent just observed that my occasional seriousness "goes a little beyond fun." Like, am I sounding dangerous or something? I dunno.
 Of course if this wasn't fun, I woudn't do it. And if it wasn't serious, I wouldn't do it either.
 So I'm sorry: you're gonna have to have it both ways.
 
Vanity on hold 
 "Due to the enormous popularity of our new products, the normal wait times on our help line have increased. Our estimated wait time is now... nine minutes." That's what Eudora's help line keeps telling me, over bad Chinese restaurant music. The Voice is that same insincere rent-a-dude you hear on about a third of these systems. His voice is so deep he must have a larnyx the size of a water culvert. "If you would like to leave a message..." Well, I left an email message yesterday and all I got was a useless automated response promising an eventual human one if the automated one proved predictably inadequate. That response hasn't arrived. "Personal attention takes time. Thank you for your patience while we provide this level of service to other customers..." Fuck.
 Okay, credit where due: they said it would take nine minutes, and it took about that, I guess. Seemed like five years, but hey.
 More credit: the help worked. I needed to relocate my old Eudora folder to my personaldocuments directory. I forgot this was Unix. And I shoulda known, too.
 Suggestions to companies everywhere:
 
  1. Don't insult tech support callers with suggestions they leave messages or send emails or look on the Web site, or press * for Frequently Asked Questions or any other stuff they've probably already done already or they wouldn't be sitting on hold.
  2. Get rid of the insincere voiceover guy. Just say "We're sorry this is gonna take some time. We're guessing around __ minutes."
  3. Add "Press X to mute the hold music" to the menu.
 
Dept. of Redundancy Dept. 
 In case you don't read long posts and missed the link in the long piece below, go straight to George Lakoff's Metaphors of Terror. It's about as deep as Deep Shit gets. Also one more reason why George is my guru (or, since we're both from New Jersey, my fuckin' guru).
 
Another jackhammer at work 
 Now Dean has a doppelblog too. Says he plans to merge them. Or something.
 
It's a flat/round world after all 
 First, a pointer to The Connectivity Infrastructure, which is a piece I wrote for the Linux Journal site. It's about what "we" get and "they" don't, and it picks up on a number of threads various bloggers (and other sources of authority) started spinning early last week.
 "We," of course, are those who get the clues several among us wrote about in Cluetrain three years ago (yes, it was that long ago). "They" is everybody who continues to operate under the illusion that the institutional world is still a top-down place. Again, the prevailing condition:
 A powerful global conversation has begun. Through the Internet, people are discovering and inventing new ways to share relevant knowledge with blinding speed. As a direct result, markets are getting smarterãand getting smarter faster than most companies.
 But it's not just companies, of course. It's news organizations, schools and governments too.
 What we said in Cluetrain was deeply offensive to the sturdy notion that knowledge is some kind of "content" that flows down from top to bottom, from the few to the many, whether the pyramid is journalism, business, or education.
 Those last two are going to take a lot longer to die, so let's turn to the topic that's closest to home here in blogland: Journalism.
 Start with J.D.'s blog. The man is totally on the case. His blog tirelessly monitors the failing vital signs of Journalism as Usual. Whether it's ABC & Fox's gun-jumping on the Daniel Pearl case or the story of a pissy traditional print journalist getting brained by an equally-credentialed blogger, every post limns another failing throb of JAU's sclerotic heart.
 As I write this, I hear Dylan singing:
 There's something happening and you don't know what it is, do you, Mr. Jones?
 And now, with Radio Userland, Dave and his cohorts have turned blogs into bludgeons, supplying writers with $39.95 jackhammers custom built to pound Journalism As Usual into the dirt.
 The question is, why is it still there?
 The obvious answer is the conservative one: JAU is an institution, after all, and these things by nature are big and tough and tend to last a long time. As Craig Burton once said (about a big old company), "It's a snake that circles the world. It'll take a long time for the tail to know the head is dead." And, of course, some of it deserves to live. There's a legitimate market for good journalism, and the media that carry it. Just not for some of its conceits.
 The reason those conceits stand is largely conceptual. We literally conceive institutions in hierarchical terms. They have verticality built into the way we understand and talk about them.
 Read George Lakoff on Metaphors of Terror. Without ever realizing it, we see buildings as heads, which is exactly why Osama and his boys shot us through the biggest head they could find. (And we felt it, too.)
 We express that verticality in our BigCo buildings, in our BigCo org charts, and in the subtexts of expressions like "who are you to say..." It shows up in the caste systems that comprises every institution, the honors it bestows, and the silent potocols it can't help but trust.
 But there are new reputation mechanisms in place now, with Google's bots constantly mapping their connections. These mechanisms may have their hierarchical aspects, but they aren't especially vertical. Yes, I have a good reputation and a high profile on some subjects; but if I stop writing tomorrow, it will be as if I pulled out my own batteries. You'll find me on Google, but I'll be receding into the nether pages. Same is true for the rest of us.
 "I sing the body electric," Whitman wrote:
 The curious sympathy one feels, when feeling with the hand the naked meat of the body,
The circling rivers, the breath, and breathing it in and out,
The beauty of the waist, and thence of the hips, and thence downward toward the knees,
The thin red jellies within you, or within meãthe bones, and the marrow in the bones,
The exquisite realization of health;
O I say, these are not the parts and poems of the Body only, but of the Soul,
O I say now these are the Soul!
 The Net is an electric body too. Whether it's as round as the Earth, or as flat as the planet looks on its surface, it's not a safe habitat for terminal elites, no matter what the're about.
 We are an electric body, and we won't support any more pointless pyramids.
 
Rahul Fu 
 Rahul started a thread about the wider-fi topic on the Decentralization list last September. Worth revisiting.
 
What's a little PR among friends? 
 Hey, Chris & Leo! Maybe you could lean on John Dvorak and the TechTV people to put a bunch of serious bloggers on Silicon Spin. And if John wants to be a stick in the mud about it, something on Screen Savers would be cool, no?
 By the way, John is one of the guys who does get stuff (and gives it too, with the best of them). He's coming from the mass market mentality on blogs. His thinking goes, "if the majority of blogs are purely self-indulgent, then blogging must be about self-indulgence." If he thinks blogs are only about vanity, he misses a lot of boats.
 
Which means he still doesn't get it. 
 John Dvorak's piece on blogs is finally up. He likes them and lists five "obvious possibilities" why "Web log addicts" blog. Nowhere does the word "journal," "journalist" or "journalism" show up in the piece. To him blogs just lower the threshold for "vanity sites." Their main upside: "far fewer cat pictures."
 
Mesh Fu 
 Kevin Marks writes, pointing me to a wider kind of wireless: Mesh Networks. Looks to me like yet another network, kind of like Ricochet was, only without the centralized infrastructure. I think the best bet for what I yesterday called Condition B is to transport TCP/IP over the existing digital cell phone system by adding efficiencies to that system.




Copyright 2009 The Doc Searls Weblog

Membership : Join Now : Login

Create your own Manila site in minutes. Everyone's doing it!

Click to see the XML version of this web page.

Blogroll

 
Search archives

Santa Barbarians
Edhat
SB Independent
SB Newsroom
Kevin Barron
Blogabarbara
Craig Smith
SB*Free Press
Joe Andieu
Patrick Gregston
John Quiimby
Das Williams' dad
Katy Pearce
Taymar Pixley
Lisa Gates
Cookie Jill

Everybody else
Spot-on
RageBoy
MysticBourgeoisie
David Weinberger
Miscellaneous
Dave
Berkman
John Palfrey
IT Garage
Bret Fausett
Susan Crawford
Bruce Sterling
Steve Lewis/Bubkes
Hak Pak Sak
Brad Kava
Brad Templeton
Sheila Lennon
Don Marti
Steve Urquhart
Wes Felter
Brad DeLong
Tom Evslin
Brian Oberkirch
Dean Landsman
Hugh MacLeod
LAist
Jeremy Ruston
Geoff Jones
Vaspers the Grate
Sig Rinde
Chris Albritton
Ronni Bennett
Thomas Hawk
Kevin Bedell
Howard
Bryan
Deep Fun
BoingBoing
edhat
Terry Heaton
Jay Rosen
Kim Cameron
George Lakoff
Scott Rosenberg
Larry Lessig
Jim Thompson
Jeff Jarvis
David Isenberg
Stephen Johnson
Tim Oren
Geoff Moore
Rex Hammock
This is Broken
Max Sawicky
Stuart Hughes
Dave Pentecost
John Perry Barlow
Mary Hodder
Dan Gillmor
Steve Gillmor
Dean Landsman
John Stodder
Seth Finkelstein
Renee Blodgett
misbehaving.net
Ruby Sinreich
Ed Cone
Julie Leung
Ted Leung
Ken Coar
Flemming Funch
Mike Sanders
Marc Canter
Joi Ito
Ethan Zuckerman
Doug Kaye
Jon Lebkowski
Judith Meskill
Allen Searls
Esther Dyson
Christopher Lydon
Russell Beattie
Tim Bray
Brian Millar
Mark Pilgrim
Michael Hall
Backup Brain
Frankston, Reed
Britt Blaser
Brent Simmons
Loic Le Meur
Leslie Winer
Mike Taht
Eric Raymond
Volokh Conspiracy
Steven Levy
Lisa Rein
Skywave
Epeus' epigone
Glenn Reynolds
James Taranto
Frank Paynter
Ross Mayfield
Dana Blankenhorn
Ken Bereskin/Panther
Daily Wireless
Filchyboy
OxBlog
Bryan Field-Elliot
Rajesh Jain
Oliver Willis
Gary Turner
Michael O'Connor Clarke
Jennifer Balderama
Kevin Werbach
Amy Wohl
Phil Windley
Fulcrum
Real Joe
Greater Democracy
Mitch Ratcliffe /biz
Mitch Ratcliffe/soc
Wayne Robins
VivaCapitalism
Cut on the bias
Howard Greenstein
The Poor Man
Mickey Kaus
Dave Sifry
Buzz Bruggeman
Ben Hammersley
Matt Jones
Paul Andrews
John Robb
Schoolblog
Tom Shugart
Matt Welch
Blur Circle
Denise Howell
JY
BlackHoleBrain
Chris Pirillo
Marek
Tony Pierce
Chris Nolan's
Spot On

Wil Wheaton
Meg
Brian Linse
Dan Pink
Dawn Olsen
Craig
Yoz
The Head Lemur
Ev
Jeremy Zawodny
Susan Kitchens
K5
Anu Gupta
Jonathon
Fishrush
Dave Ely
Euan Semple
Eric Norlin
Paul Boutin
James Lileks
David Williams
Mary Wehmeier
Bruner Blog
Halley Suitt
Webword
Ann Salisbury
Om Malik
Moxie
J's Notes
Meesh
NUblog
TBTF
Cam
Seth Finkelstein
Tom Matrullo
Chip Hoagland
Deborah
Fortboise
J.D. Lasica
Photodude
Phil Wolff
Andre Durand
Eric Hansen
Mike McBride
Jeneane Sessum
Chris Nolan
Gonzo Engaged
Michael Mussington
UseTheSource
Wes
Adam
Sam Ruby
Miguel
Frank Field
Rebecca Blood
Joshua Allen
Cluetrain
JOHO
EGR
Searls site
Scoble
AKMA
Kottke
Tomalak's Realm
Tim O'Reilly
Mitch Kapor
Bill Quick
Dan Bricklin
Lou Josephs
Alan Reiter
N.Z. Bear
Todd Morman
Zeldman
Glenn
Joshua
Rex Hammock
Matthew Thomas
Brian Dear
Baylink
Burningbird